This Cherry Chocolate Banana Ice Cream captures the flavors of a favorite pint—real cherries and chocolate pieces—in a dairy-free take on Cherry Garcia.
We’re in the middle of a heat wave, with temperatures in the 90s and no relief in sight. The beach was hot and still this weekend, but cold treats saved the day. After a few days of intense heat I often lose my appetite until my body adjusts, but I always crave something cool and refreshing.
When I’m at home, my go-to is a form of banana-based ice cream. A few years back I posted a no-churn Double Chocolate Chip Banana Ice Cream that remains a favorite because it’s effortless. Still, I enjoy experimenting with whatever fresh fruit is on hand.
My husband adores Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia, and I love recreating a similar experience at home—without fussing over an ice cream maker or churning. Instead I keep it simple: blend the ingredients in a high-powered blender like a Vitamix, freeze briefly if you want scoopable texture, and enjoy. For a quick fix I often skip the final freezing step and eat it directly from the blender as a thick, smoothie-style treat.
For this version I halved fresh cherries from the fridge, but frozen cherries work well too. You can also swirl some cherry purée into the base for a pinker appearance if you like a visually bold dessert.
About cherries
Cherries are a delicious summer fruit packed with antioxidants. They offer anti-inflammatory benefits, can help reduce muscle soreness after exercise, and may support healthy sleep. Adding cherries to a frozen treat is a delicious and nutritious way to cool down.
Why you’ll love this Cherry Chocolate Banana Ice Cream
- Creamy, banana-based texture
- Rich chocolate chunks for contrast
- Bright, tart cherry flavor
- Refreshing and satisfying on hot days
- Free from the top 8 major allergens, making it allergy-friendly
- Simple to make with minimal equipment
Enjoy this recipe as a quick blender treat or freeze it for a firmer, scoopable dessert.
Don’t forget to PIN IT…
What’s your favorite way to cool down on a hot summer day?
XO
Let’s get social!
If you try a recipe from C it Nutritionally I’d love to see your creation—tag your photos or use the hashtag #CitNutritionally.
Facebook: C it Nutritionally
Twitter: @ChelseyAmerRD
Instagram: @CitNutritionally
Pinterest: ChelseyAmer